@mbakmer63 I agree with @Benjamin Silber, Ph.D., ABPP. It can certainly depend and I think we have to look at it on a case by case basis. I agree with you though that there are many cases in which this has occurred. I would add that this is not specific only to psychology, however. It occurs in other fields of scientific study as well.
Thank you for your comments my only response is why the duplication issue that repeated research does not replicate the same findings ?